View Full Version : Take ideas?



Moonsouth
03-07-2010, 09:33 PM
I was wondering if its accepted that I "steal" an idea that another state has used for a cache....i was thinking like a http://www.geocaching.com/seek/cache_details.aspx?wp=GC11E8N&Submit6=Go

Except in Maine.....and possibly without the no caches before certain time...what do you guys think?

brdad
03-07-2010, 10:00 PM
As long as your version is ok with our local approver I don't know why you couldn't do it.

I'm not sure I'd limit caches before a certain time; I'd more likely limit caches after a certain time. That prevents people from hiding caches to make the challenge easier.

Ekidokai
03-07-2010, 10:02 PM
We have a similar cache called the Maine adventure cache challenge.

Moonsouth
03-07-2010, 10:10 PM
Is there a compiled list of all these adventure/challenges in maine, has anyone done it?

Ekidokai
03-07-2010, 10:14 PM
Brdad is the guru on those things.

brdad
03-07-2010, 10:29 PM
None like it in Maine that I am aware of.

Bookmark list of Fizzy challenges:
http://www.geocaching.com/bookmarks/view.aspx?guid=828b4350-62d9-425b-96f5-6266804203a8

U.S. Challenge Caches: States A-G Bookmark List (http://www.geocaching.com/bookmarks/view.aspx?guid=0a3e1a81-39d8-45c9-bfb3-7fe026bf883d)
U.S. Challenge Caches: States H-M Bookmark List (http://www.geocaching.com/bookmarks/view.aspx?guid=92ae789f-c22b-4cea-a6df-c0b9c5679216)
U.S. Challenge Caches: States N-S Bookmark List (http://www.geocaching.com/bookmarks/view.aspx?guid=47a65d48-7c6a-4f28-ba9f-1925b1621db1)
U.S. Challenge Caches: States T-W Bookmark List (http://www.geocaching.com/bookmarks/view.aspx?guid=a9cbc2c6-0d34-4e99-b112-ca51819e2ef6)

Ekidokai
03-08-2010, 11:59 AM
I just took a quick look, but this seems similar. Maine's Adventure Challenge (http://www.geocaching.com/seek/cache_details.aspx?guid=9538f1ae-c65a-415f-8e80-3710ae0f11c3) GC1VWN8.

The difference is the Difficulty and Terrain.

I'm not saying I would not do your challenge idea, I just wanted you to be aware of the similar challenge.

cano
03-08-2010, 02:48 PM
I just took a quick look, but this seems similar. Maine's Adventure Challenge (http://www.geocaching.com/seek/cache_details.aspx?guid=9538f1ae-c65a-415f-8e80-3710ae0f11c3) GC1VWN8.

The difference is the Difficulty and Terrain.

I'm not saying I would not do your challenge idea, I just wanted you to be aware of the similar challenge.

FTF on this challenge :)

hollora
03-08-2010, 08:28 PM
To me the Maine adventure challenge and a Fizzy Challenge are not even on level playing fields. The only closeness, to me, is the Fizzy does require you to have one of all the cache types in the combination of 81 caches you must do.

Finding 6 caches and a coin with an icon you don't already have is a honorable daily adventure - for sure. But not the same playing field as Fizzy.

I believe there are a few on here who have either completed a Fizzy or are working on it. Perhaps they will comment on this thread.

Last time I looked, even without caches excluded by date of find, I am a long way from completing what it would take for a Fizzy. Now the Maine Adventure, I see that happening in a well planned day of caching - with it as a goal.

Publish one and they will come (eventually).

tat
03-08-2010, 09:07 PM
You may also want to read the terms and conditions, they spell out the legalities of intellectual property and copyright infringement.

But, it's probably easier to ask the cache owner. Usually, this is perceived as the highest compliment! You will probably make someone's day.

Gob-ler
03-08-2010, 09:34 PM
Having done the Fizzy and reading the Cache Adventures Thing, it is good that I was not up there or the FTF would have gone to someone else. The Fizzy took months to complete and there were more than a couple of the Fizzy caches that were quite the challenge.

There are Several Fizzy's out there including one in MA I believe. Usually if you have qualified for one you can find and log the others unless there are state restrictions and I am not aware of any of the latter.

Good luck with the cache Idea. It is a big challenge and a worthwhile undertaking.

Moonsouth
03-08-2010, 09:57 PM
I was just reading some of the guidelines and something was written about ALR's, and them not being allowed....how does it apply to these types of challenge caches?


""Logging of All Physical Caches

Geocaches can be logged online as Found once the physical log has been signed.
If it is appropriate for your cache location or theme, you may ask the cache seeker to accomplish an optional and simple task, either close to the cache site (normally within 0.1 miles or 161 meters) or when writing their online log. For example, wear the goofy hat inside the cache container and upload a photograph. Cache finders can choose whether or not to attempt or accomplish optional tasks. Cache owners may not delete the cache seeker's log based solely on optional tasks.
This guideline change applies immediately to all logs written from April 4, 2009 and going forward. Older caches with "additional logging requirements" (ALRs) are not grandfathered under the older guideline. If you own an existing cache with mandatory additional logging requirements, we request that you:


Cease deleting logs based on additional logging requirements.
Review your own cache listing to see if the ALR can be made into an optional and simple task, or whether it must be removed altogether.
Adjust your geocache listing by editing the text then contact a reviewer to change the cache type, if appropriate.""

tat
03-09-2010, 06:48 AM
Mystery or Puzzle Caches

...
Challenge caches incorporate special logging requirements and are listed as Mystery/Puzzle caches. Typically they require the seeker to have previously met a reasonable geocaching-related qualification (Waymarking and Wherigo qualify too, of course) such as first finding a cache in every county in your state. If you are thinking of creating such a cache, please include a note to the reviewer demonstrating either that you have met the challenge yourself, or that a substantial number of other geocachers would be able to do so.

The intent of the two guidelines is to prevent the negative effects of log deletion without eliminating challenge caches.

Moonsouth
03-09-2010, 07:59 AM
Ahh ok so I should have read more into it. These Mystery or Puzzle Caches are the exception. Thanks! I will be putting something together soon I think.