Something else seemed fishey to me about this cache so I went to look at the logs.

A cacher named groove&co noted that when they first looked for it, it was called Folgers and that is the name that I found it under. Apparently the owner changed the name when they changed the write up.

BRDAD I think that you were there after the cache was gone and met the requirements of the cache as listed at the time.

Lee is quite certain there was a cache there when we went, in a tree. She is looking through her notebooks now. I suppose I could have thought the cache was a virtual. But my online log still sounds suspicious. I will be changing my log to a note if I conclude we didn't find the cache.
When I found it, it was a coffee can in the rocks along the east shore. I think the picture by Team Darcins Digs shows the cache location well.